News
Refurbished iPhone vs new iPhone: when refurbished wins, when it doesn't
If you are weighing up a refurbished iPhone vs new, you are probably looking at a price tag from Apple and wondering whether the same phone, a year or two younger in the box but older in life, is worth the saving. For most Australians buying with their own money, the answer is yes. But not always. This guide sets out where a refurbished iPhone wins clearly, where a new one is still the smarter buy, and how to tell which camp you are in. The quick answer A refurbished iPhone wins when you want a recent model at a lower price, you are happy with a phone that is fully working but may show light cosmetic wear, and you want a long warranty included. At the time of writing, Apple sells a new iPhone 17 (256GB) for A$1,549 and a new iPhone 16 (128GB) for A$1,349. The same models refurbished start from $1,279 and $949 respectively at Mobile Federation, in As New and Excellent condition. A new iPhone still makes sense if you want this year's model on release day, a battery at 100% health, or the very longest possible software runway because you plan to keep the phone for six years or more. What you actually save: new vs refurbished iPhone prices Price is the main reason people look at refurbished, so here are real numbers. Apple's own Australian store lists the iPhone 17 at A$1,549 for 256GB and the iPhone 16 at A$1,349 for 128GB. Those are the new prices we checked today. Here is what the same phones cost refurbished, as checked on our store on the same morning: iPhone 17, 256GB: from $1,279 in As New condition. That is $270 less than Apple's new price for the same storage. iPhone 16, 128GB: from $949 in Excellent condition, or $999 in As New. That is $350 to $400 under Apple's new price. The gap gets wider as you step back a generation or two. An Apple iPhone 15 with 256GB of storage is from $799 in Excellent condition, an iPhone 14 with 256GB is from $569 in Good condition, and an iPhone 13 with 256GB is from $459 in Good condition. For older models like these, refurbished is where the biggest savings sit. Prices on refurbished phones move as stock comes and goes, so treat these as a snapshot rather than a fixed price list. The useful rule of thumb is this: the newer the model, the smaller the percentage saving; the older the model, the bigger the saving, and the more you should look at battery health and software support before you buy. When refurbished wins You want a recent iPhone without paying the new-phone premium. This is the classic case. An iPhone 16 or 17 is still a current, fast phone. Buying it refurbished means the first owner has already absorbed the steepest part of the price drop. You do not mind light, honest wear. A refurbished phone is fully tested and fully working, and the condition grade tells you how it looks. As New means no scratches on the screen and next to no signs of wear on the body. Excellent may have light micro-scratches. Good shows visible scratches on the body but works exactly the same. If you put a case on your phone the day you get it, the cheaper grade is often the better value. Our guide to refurbished phone grading shows what each grade looks like. You want to save on iPhone without dropping too far back. Apple's iOS 27 supports the iPhone 11 and every iPhone since, so even a three or four-year-old model is still on Apple's current software today. That makes something like an iPhone 15 or iPhone 16 a sensible middle ground: modern features, years of updates left, and a much lower price than new. You are buying for someone else. A first phone for a teenager, a replacement for a parent, a spare for work. These are the situations where paying full new price rarely makes sense, and where a solid warranty matters more than the box being sealed. When a new iPhone is the better buy It would not be honest to say refurbished always wins. There are good reasons to buy new. You want the newest model on day one. Refurbished stock of a brand-new model takes time to appear, and the saving is smallest in the first few months. If having the latest phone the week it launches is the point, buy new. You plan to keep the phone for six years or more. Every iPhone eventually drops off Apple's update list. Buying the newest model gives you the longest possible runway. If you are buying refurbished with a very long horizon in mind, choose a recent model rather than the cheapest one. You want a battery at 100% health. A new iPhone starts at full battery capacity. A refurbished one has been used, so its battery has some wear. Every phone we sell has at least 80% battery health, which is enough for a full day for most people, but it is not the same as brand new. If battery life is your top priority, look at listings with a higher battery health option, or consider new. The phone is part of a plan you already want. Some people prefer to bundle a new phone into a monthly arrangement. That is a different kind of purchase from buying a phone outright, and this guide does not try to compare the two. What to check before you buy refurbished Whichever way you lean, a few checks protect you: Warranty length. Read the seller's policy, not just the product page. Look for how long it lasts and what it covers. Battery health. Ask for a minimum figure. You can check it yourself in Settings, then Battery, then Battery Health. Condition grade definitions. Make sure the seller explains what each grade means in plain words, ideally with photos. Returns. A change-of-mind window gives you time to check the phone in your own hands. Your consumer rights. Under Australian Consumer Law, a refurbished phone still has to be of acceptable quality and match its description. The ACCC's guide to consumer guarantees explains how that works. If you want the bigger picture on what happens to a phone before it is resold, our explainer on what a refurbished phone is walks through testing and grading step by step. Where Mobile Federation fits We are an Australian store that sells refurbished iPhones, Samsung Galaxy and Google Pixel phones outright, with free express shipping. Each phone passes a 72-point inspection and is 100% functional, whatever its grade. Two years of cover comes standard: if a manufacturing fault or hardware failure shows up in that time, our 24-month warranty means we repair it, replace it with the same model, or refund you. It does not cover accidental damage such as drops or liquid. You also get 30 days to return the phone if it is not right for you. If you are deciding between two recent models, our iPhone 15 vs iPhone 16 comparison is a good next read. Frequently asked questions Is a refurbished iPhone as good as new? It works the same. A properly refurbished iPhone is fully tested and functional. The differences are cosmetic condition, which the grade describes, and battery health, which will be below 100% but at least 80% at Mobile Federation. How much can I save buying a refurbished iPhone instead of new? As checked on 26 October 2026, a refurbished iPhone 17 (256GB) was from $1,279 against Apple's new price of A$1,549, and a refurbished iPhone 16 (128GB) was from $949 against A$1,349. Prices change with stock. Will a refurbished iPhone still get iOS updates? Yes, if the model is still supported. Apple's iOS 27 supports the iPhone 11 and later, so any iPhone from the iPhone 11 onwards still gets Apple's latest software. When should I buy a new iPhone instead? Buy new if you want the latest model as soon as it launches, a battery at 100% health, or the longest possible software support because you plan to keep the phone for many years. Compare refurbished iPhones See today's prices and condition grades across our full range of refurbished Apple iPhones, each with two years of warranty included.
Read moreNews
